Veuillez utiliser cette adresse pour citer ce document : https://hdl.handle.net/10953/1133
Titre: Aggregation Bias in Estimates of Conditional Conservatism: Theory and Evidence
Auteur(s): CANO-RODRÍGUEZ, MANUEL
NÚÑEZ-NICKEL, MANUEL
Résumé: This paper documents a study about the influence of the aggregation effect on the estimates of models based on the original Basu model – specifically the Ball, Kothari, and Nikolaev model (Ball et al., 2013b). We provide an analytical study of the effect, showing that it can produce two biases: an omitted-variable bias and a truncated-sample bias. Using separate proxies for good and bad news for each company and year, we estimate the empirical sign and magnitude of those biases. Our results show that the estimates of conditional conservatism based on regressions of (unexpected) earnings on (unexpected) returns, as in Ball et al. (2013b), are contaminated by substantial aggregation bias. More specifically, the aggregation effect causes these models to underestimate good-news timeliness and overestimate bad-news timeliness, thereby overestimating differential timeliness. Moreover, when we use proxies that provide better control for the aggregation effect, the differential timeliness coefficient tends to 0, showing that the influence of conditional conservatism on the returns–earnings relationship is at best marginal.
Mots-clés: accounting conservatism
conditional conservatism
returns–earnings relationship
aggregation effect
Date de publication: jan-2015
metadata.dc.description.sponsorship: This research is funded by the SEJ2007-65782-C02-02ECON and the ECO201022105-C03-03 (subprogram ECON) research projects of the Spanish Ministry of Science and Education, and the INFOINNOVA research project of the Community of Madrid.
Editeur: Wiley
Collection(s) :DEFC-Artículos

Fichier(s) constituant ce document :
Fichier Description TailleFormat 
AGGREGATION BIAS IN ESTIMATES OF CONDITIONAL CONSERVATISM (accepted version).docx229,96 kBMicrosoft Word XMLVoir/Ouvrir


Ce document est protégé par copyright


Ce document est autorisé sous une licence de type Licence Creative Commons
Creative Commons